Risk Mitigation Strategies for Investing in South African Mines
Source: Carlos Muza on Unsplash
For over a century, mining has been a cornerstone of South Africa’s economic strength and remains a key player today. Despite a two-decade slowdown in the gold mining sector, South Africa ranks within the world’s top 10 gold producers, offering investors reliable diversification options for their portfolios, both sector-wise and geographically.
Investing in emerging markets like South Africa comes with its set of challenges, primarily due to the higher risks compared to more developed nations, especially under tough global economic and geopolitical climates. Yet, these markets also promise potentially greater rewards. They boast demographics more favorable for growth than those of developed nations, possess a quicker pace of development, and tend to be more dynamic and innovative when tackling problems. With the right risk management strategies, investors can reap the benefits of assets that not only diversify their portfolios but also present opportunities for capital appreciation.
This article aims to shed light on the investment landscape in South Africa, particularly within the gold mining sector. It discusses how diversifying investments can safeguard against the risks of a US economic downturn and how the stable value of gold can protect assets during periods of economic and geopolitical instability.
While South Africa’s gold mining sector faces its share of obstacles, Pan African Resources has taken these challenges in stride, adjusting its operational strategies and long-term plans to navigate and mitigate these risks effectively. The company’s strong performance has yet to be fully recognized in its stock valuation, suggesting significant growth potential for investors who prioritize sustainable practices and seek to align with a firm that acknowledges the importance of today’s environmental, social, and governance decisions for future prosperity and success.
Understanding the South African Market
Mining has been pivotal to South Africa’s economic narrative, with the sector’s exports reaching $575 billion in the first six months of this year, making up nearly 60% of the nation’s total exports, as reported by the South African Revenue Services. Additionally, the industry provides employment for nearly 500,000 individuals in a country grappling with over 30% joblessness, thus playing a vital role in the economic and social well-being of South Africa.
Although no longer the world’s top gold producer, South Africa remains a significant player, ranking eighth globally. A recent study by PWC, SA Mine 2023: Adapt to Thrive, indicates that the decrease in gold production since the mid-2000s can be attributed to the anticipated closure of existing mines within the next 20 years without further investment.
Recent times have seen a more positive outlook for the industry, with companies investing in exploration and innovation likely to see the most benefit. Gold production has seen a steady increase since 2020, and the combination of stronger commodity prices and a weaker local currency has helped offset rising costs due to inflation.
Despite these positive trends, the gold mining sector faces several challenges, including ongoing electricity supply issues, which have led to equipment failures, production disruptions, and safety concerns. Inflation on imported machinery adds to the cost burdens, and the industry must navigate the uncertain economic landscape expected to continue into 2024. Challenges such as illegal mining activities and a lack of skilled workers also persist.
Pan African Resources is addressing these challenges by increasingly shifting towards renewable energy sources and improving energy efficiency. The company has undertaken numerous cost-reduction and hedging initiatives to manage the fluctuations in currency and gold prices. It’s also deeply invested in community partnerships to enhance living standards and promote socio-economic growth.
In the last two years, significant strides have been made towards the goal of sourcing 50% of energy needs from renewables by 2035. Notably, the 10MW Evander solar project, launched in 2022, now supplies 30% of the Evander mine’s energy requirements. Further projects are underway to transform the energy portfolio across the company’s operations.
Addressing Geopolitical Risks
The global landscape is increasingly marked by geopolitical tensions, highlighted by the economic strain between the US and China, the conflict in Ukraine, and the recent escalations in Israel-Palestinian relations that threaten stability in the Middle East and potentially beyond.
Amidst these challenges, gold has stood out by maintaining its value in rand terms since July 2021, reinforcing its status as a refuge during uncertain times, much to the benefit of the South African gold mining sector. These global upheavals have introduced a new level of volatility, making assets like gold more attractive as they tend to outperform in such environments.
https://www.pwc.co.za/en/assets/pdf/sa-mine-2023-v3.pdf
The gold mining industry is often impacted by the potential for changes in mining laws, taxation, and political stability, especially in Africa. This was underscored in August when Mali adjusted its policy on local ownership, now requiring up to a 35% stake for local investors and the government, an increase from the previous 20%. In contrast, South Africa has avoided such demands on mining companies, focusing instead on ensuring that the benefits of mining extend to historically marginalized communities through ownership, business opportunities, and social initiatives.
On a regulatory and policy level, South Africa stands out positively both regionally and against more developed markets. The country’s fiscal policies and legal frameworks are highly regarded, supported by robust and liquid financial markets. While there’s a need for structural reforms in certain sectors and improvements in business operations, companies are largely compliant with existing regulations. South Africa’s advanced banking system also ensures that foreign entities face no hurdles in repatriating funds or in VAT recovery, unlike the challenges faced by Barrick in Tanzania and the DRC.
Pan African Resources places a strong emphasis on building social and relational capital, understanding its value in fostering community goodwill, mitigating socio-economic and political risks, and ensuring long-term business sustainability. The company adopts an approach that goes beyond mere compliance to meet the highest standards of regulatory adherence and ethical business conduct, along with maintaining strong stakeholder relationships.
The company’s commitment to sustainability ensures that all stakeholders share in the benefits derived from its long-standing mining operations. This includes ventures in renewable energy, agriculture, land restoration, and ongoing efforts to create jobs and drive economic growth within local communities.
Agile Adaptation to Market Dynamics
Pan African Resources, as a mid-tier mining entity, boasts the operational flexibility and innovative spirit necessary to swiftly and effectively adjust to evolving economic conditions. The company has proactively addressed the growing challenges of electricity supply in South Africa by accelerating its shift towards renewable energy sources from traditional grid power.
The company’s dynamic and results-oriented culture has further allowed it to expand its gold mining portfolio through both organic growth and strategic projects aimed at boosting production. By employing advanced exploration techniques and strategic planning, Pan African Resources has broadened its asset base to include a mix of sustainable, high-grade underground and cost-efficient surface mining operations. Additionally, the company has secured extensive mining rights, extending to 2038 at Evander Mines and 2051 at Barberton Mines.
Notably, two of its ventures, the Rolspruit and Egoli projects, are recognized in GlobalData’s list of the top 10 significant gold mine developments, as featured in the Global Mining to 2026 Report. Initiatives like these underscore the company’s commitment to becoming a long-term, safe, high-margin gold producer.
Transparency and Reliability of Information
In an era marked by complex global economic and geopolitical challenges, the rise in corruption and criminal activities is alarming, and the mining industry is not immune to these ethical dilemmas. Given this context, investors are increasingly demanding complete transparency and thorough due diligence from companies before committing their capital, with a zero-tolerance policy towards corruption and a keen interest in the security of mining rights.
In alignment with these expectations, Pan African Resources is dedicated to maintaining transparency and eradicating any unethical practices that might affect its operations and stakeholder value. The company has implemented several initiatives to this end, including the formation of an audit and risk committee by the board, the establishment of an ethical conduct code, the regular review and update of its corporate malpractice policy, and the introduction of an anonymous whistleblowing hotline for employees and external service providers.
To comply with international standards like the UK Bribery Act, the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, and the South African Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act, Pan African Resources has adopted a formal policy against bribery and corruption.
The company also upholds the highest governance standards, with a diverse and skilled Board of Directors committed to governing the company in a responsible, ethical, and transparent manner. Independent audits of the Group’s financial statements and quarterly reviews of the whistleblowing register by the board’s audit and risk committee further reflect the company’s commitment to integrity, transparency, and accountability in all its business practices.
Financial Performance and Dividend Payouts
In the 2023 fiscal year, Pan African Resources demonstrated robust and consistent financial performance, reinforcing the viewpoint among analysts that its shares are undervalued and present a compelling opportunity for investors.
Despite challenges, including lower production outputs from underground operations due to power supply issues, the company benefited from a favorable rand gold price, which offset these production shortfalls. Pan African Resources is taking steps to enhance production at its Barberton Mines and has raised its production outlook for the 2024 financial year, anticipating continued strong growth if the gold price remains stable.
The company also continued its tradition of rewarding shareholders with substantial dividends, even while funding significant capital projects like the construction of the MTR project.
Despite apprehensions that the shift towards renewable energy could raise operational expenses for mining enterprises, Pan African Resources’ journey tells a different story. The company’s deliberate investments in sustainable initiatives, notably in solar energy projects, have effectively curtailed energy expenditures. This achievement is particularly significant given the rising electricity tariffs imposed by Eskom, South Africa’s primary electricity supplier. The Group’s proactive adaptation of its energy mix in recent years, incorporating innovative exploration and sustainable practices like solar power installations, has not only countered the potential cost increases but also led to tangible reductions in energy costs at Elikhulu, amidst Eskom’s ongoing and anticipated electricity price surges well above inflation.
Diversification as a Risk Mitigation Strategy
The inherent volatility of emerging markets is often balanced by the potential for higher returns, making them an attractive proposition for investors seeking diversified portfolios. Companies in these markets are typically more agile and resilient, having adapted to various challenges.
Pan African Resources’ experience challenges the notion that obtaining operational permits in emerging markets is more cumbersome than in developed countries. For instance, securing a permit for the Mintails project in South Africa took significantly less time than the lengthy almost decade long processes often encountered in North America.
Investors considering geographic and sectoral diversification should look towards the South African gold mining sector, where Pan African Resources stands out for its promising growth prospects and diversified risk profile.
The company remains focused on gold mining, leveraging organic growth opportunities without venturing into other metals like copper or platinum group metals. It prioritizes optimizing its current operations, enhancing production efficiency, and employing innovative mining techniques to extend the life of its mines.
While organic growth is the primary strategy, Pan African Resources remains open to strategic acquisitions that meet its rigorous investment criteria, ensuring any such moves align with shareholder value enhancement and return optimization.
Pan African Resources’ dedicated focus on gold mining capitalizes on the enduring organic growth prospects within this sector. The company is currently not venturing into other metals like copper or platinum group metals (PGMs), choosing instead to optimize its existing operations. This involves refining production processes, enhancing the output of current assets, and innovating mining techniques to minimize waste and boost efficiency, especially as some ore deposits begin to diminish.
While the company’s main strategy emphasizes organic growth, it remains open to exploring acquisitions that meet its stringent criteria for investment, ensuring any new ventures align with its goals of enhancing shareholder value and achieving higher returns.
Pan African Resources is actively seeking to broaden its investor base, particularly focusing on the US market. The company aims to attract investors looking for opportunities beyond the potential economic downturns in the US, emphasizing sustainable investments as key to long-term prosperity. This initiative to reach out to US investors who share a vision for sustainability has seen a notable increase in American shareholder participation in the company, growing from less than 2% to approximately 6% over the last year.
The investment appeal in gold and gold-related assets remains strong, with gold historically outperforming both the broader stock market and fiat currencies over the long term. As the global economic landscape evolves, with a growing emphasis on de-dollarization, gold’s role as a stable investment is expected to become even more significant.
Countries from the Global South, encompassing emerging economies in Africa, Latin America, Asia, and Oceania, are actively seeking alternatives to reduce their reliance on Western financial systems and the US dollar. Concurrently, China’s strategic shift away from US Treasury bonds towards bolstering its gold reserves marks a significant realignment in global economic strategies, underscoring the strategic importance of gold in the emerging multipolar world order.
Risk Mitigation Strategies for South African Investing
For over a hundred years, South African gold mining firms have been pivotal, providing unique sector-specific investment opportunities. Gold and its shares have historically served as reliable safeguards against economic fluctuations and inflation, an increasingly important feature in today’s uncertain market environment.
Pan African Resources stands out as a solid investment within the wider emerging market context, meeting the diversification needs of investors. The company’s profound insights into the South African market, combined with a competent management team and durable assets, have facilitated its organic growth and resilience against both global and local adversities. The financial achievements of Pan African Resources underscore its consistent performance and dedication to upholding sustainability and ethical standards.
Investors interested in gaining a more in-depth understanding of Pan African Resources’ strategies within the local market are encouraged to undertake a thorough due diligence of the Group. During this process, the management team will provide full financial transparency and address any inquiries investors might have regarding the company’s operational effectiveness, strategic goals, and how it navigates risks both within South Africa and on a global scale.
